A Comparison of ICP-OES and ICP-MS for the Determination of Metals in Food - The determination of inorganic elements in food substances is critical for assessing nutritional composition and
A Comparison of ICP-OES and ICP-MS for the Determination of Metals in Food
The determination of inorganic elements in food substances is critical for assessing nutritional composition and identifying food contamination sources. The inorganic elements of interest can be divided into two classes: nutritional and toxic. It is important to determine the levels of both sets of elements accurately to assess both the nutritional and the harmful impacts of food substances. Nutritional elements such as Mg, P, and Fe are present at high levels (milligrams per kilogram), while toxic..
Inorganic analysis of food for metals that might be harmful to health is an important part of ensuring food safety. Metals
can contaminate raw products through exposure to contaminated soil or water during growth. Contamination during transport
is also possible. During processing, gross or trace contamination can be introduced through machinery used. Product packaging
can contribute to the contamination and was the subject of a U.S. FDA import alert describing lollipop candies contaminated
with lead from the packaging ink. Levels of metals permissible in food are not defined clearly in U.S. regulations, although
some guidance has been developed through prior encounters with contaminated food (1).
This work compares techniques for metal measurement in a variety of foods using inductively coupled plasma-optical emission
spectroscopy (ICP-OES) and inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). The suitability of the techniques for analytical
capability and productivity will be compared.
Experimental
Table I: Microwave digestion program
A variety of food samples were purchased and digested for analysis. Microwave-assisted digestion (Mutiwave 3000, PerkinElmer,
Shelton, Connecticut) was used following the program in Table I, taking approximately 0.5 g of sample in replicate and using
6 mL of nitric acid and 1 mL of hydrochloric acid (acids were Optima grade and were obtained from Fisher Scientific, Pittsburgh,
Pennsylvania).
Table II: ICP-OES conditions
The samples were analyzed using ICP-OES and ICP-MS using the parameters listed in Table II and Table III.
Results and Discussion
Table III: ICP-MS conditions
The samples were chosen to represent a variety of matrices for analysis. The U.S. FDA import alerts were used for guidance
on what types of food samples had shown unacceptable levels of toxic metals when tested for import. Although similar matrices
were chosen, predigestion spikes were used to demonstrate an elevated level of metals, because the samples were not expected
to be contaminated. Table IV shows some of the items listed in import recalls, the country of origin, the contaminating element,
and the levels observed in testing.
Samples purchased from a local grocery store included the following foods and beverages: