FT-IR and Raman: A Synergism, Not Competing Technologies - Infrared absorption and Raman scattering are two means of detecting atomic motion in molecules and crystals, which then provides information
FT-IR and Raman: A Synergism, Not Competing Technologies
Infrared absorption and Raman scattering are two means of detecting atomic motion in molecules and crystals, which then provides information on interatomic bonding, orientation, and long-range order. Because of the physical nature of the two processes, the IR and Raman spectra are not equivalent. In combination with an understanding of what affects the vibrations, the spectra can be used to derive detailed physical and chemical information about the samples of interest. As an example, the IR and Raman..
Vibrational spectra are of interest to analytical and materials scientists because of their potential to yield nondestructively
detailed information on materials. This is because the vibrations quite sensitively reflect interatomic bonding. There are
several spectroscopies in which vibrational transitions can be detected. The simplest is infrared (IR) absorption. In this
case, when a molecule is irradiated with photons whose energy corresponds to the energy of one of its vibrations (which is
in the mid- and far-IR part of the electromagnetic spectrum), those photons will be absorbed. If an instrument is built to
monitor the transmission of IR light, there will be a dip in the transmission at the energy corresponding to the vibration.
In the near IR (NIR) region, there are similar processes that correspond to absorption of overtones (multiples of a vibration)
and combinations of vibrations. Absorption in the MIR detects vibrational "fundamentals" and some higher-order transitions,
whereas the NIR detects second or higher-order processes in direct absorption. It is also possible to "scatter" off of a molecule.
When a photon in the visible part of the electromagnetic spectrum is used to initiate a scattering event, it is called Raman
scattering. By its nature, Raman is a second-order process — there are two photons, the incident laser photon, and the scattered
photon. Second-order processes in general have much lower quantum yields than first-order processes. So even though it is
easier to build spectrographs and detectors for the visible part of the spectrum, IR spectroscopy developed more rapidly during
the middle and latter part of the last century. As a consequence of the physical origin of IR absorption and Raman scattering,
the spectra appear quite different. What is intense in the IR is weak in the Raman, and vice versa, and when there is a center
of symmetry in the molecule or crystal under study, no vibrational band will appear in both spectra. Consequently, the ability
to detect both types of spectra produces a lot of information on a sample, with the potential to be more informative than
either by itself, or, indeed, the sum of the two. As an example, we will discuss here some of what can be done with two simple
polymers — polyethylene (PE) and polypropylene (PP).
In polyatomic systems, each pair of bonded atoms has three degrees of freedom to vibrate, but the atomic motion of one pair
of atoms is mixed together with adjacent atoms. Not only are there stretches, but there are bending, rocking, and torsional
motions as well. If you can imagine a stretching motion between two atoms in a complicated system, you can see quickly that
those two atoms will pull and twist other surrounding atoms. The final result is that there are "normal modes" of motion;
that is, the entire polyatomic system will exhibit vibrations where many atoms will move in concert, but each normal mode
will be independent and will not mix with other normal modes.
If a molecule is systematically modified, for example, by replacing a proton with a methyl group, the vibrations will change.
In this case, there will be new methyl group vibrations, but, in addition, the added mass attached to the modified carbon
will tug more on that carbon, which will in turn affect its normal vibrations.
Over the years, it has been shown that it is possible to use this type of analysis to characterize regions of spectra. Functional
groups such as >C=C<, >C=O<, CH (methine, methylene, methyl), SH, NH, and OH vibrate with frequencies that are well-separated
from anything else (and each other) so their bands are easily recognizable in the spectra (1,2). Below 1500 cm–1 is the "fingerprint" region, where the observed vibrations represent mixed motions of multiple atoms tugging at each other.